NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

As Halloween quickly approaches, bakeries and restaurants all over NYC are gearing up for a sugar overload. Indulge your sweet tooth in these Halloween season goodies, perfect to bring to a themed party or to treat your little ones on October 31st.

By Sarah Shaker.

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Autumn Trifle, Veniero’s

342 E.11th St.

New York, NY

212-674-7070

www.venierospastry.com/

Looking for Halloween sweets to bring to the office? Classic Italian bakery Veniero’s in the East Village offers brightly iced sugar cookies in the shapes of ghosts, vampires and Frankenstein each year. For a classier Halloween season treat, don’t miss the Autumn Trifle made from layers of spiced carrot cake, creamy New York cheesecake and pumpkin cream topping.

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

BOO Cupcakes, Magnolia Bakery

Multiple locations

New York, NY

(212) 462-2572

www.magnoliabakery.com/

Tourists flock to Magnolia for cupcakes all year round, while New Yorkers love to splurge on their indulgent banana pudding. For Halloween this year, visitors and locals alike will fall for their BOO Cupcakes. Rich devil’s food cake with orange-tinted white chocolate truffle filling is topped with velvety ganache inscribed with “BOO!” These themed cupcakes are perfect for your kids’ classroom Halloween celebration or for an adult night out filled with tricks and treats to share with friends.

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Pumpkin and Apple Gobblers, Big Gay Ice Cream Shop

125 East 7th Street

New York, NY

biggayicecream.com/

Big Gay Ice Cream’s fall Gobblers are a seasonal favorite. Choose from the Pumpkin Gobbler; vanilla soft serve, pumpkin butter, maple syrup, pie crust pieces and whipped cream and the Apple Gobbler; vanilla soft serve, apple butter, bourbon butterscotch, pie crust pieces and whipped cream. And don’t forget this winter they’ll be bringing back Mexicano Affogayto, a homemade spicy hot chocolate poured over ice cream to keep you cozy all season long.

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Halloween Yummy Mummy Colossal, Crumbs Bake Shop

Multiple locations

New York, NY

1-877-CRUMBS-0

www.crumbs.com/

A giant chocolate cake is filled and frosted with chocolate cream cheese frosting and vanilla cream cheese wraps for a mummified look, perfect to impress your guests at a Halloween party for kids of any age. This mummy look is also offered as a regular sized cupcake for individual Halloween sugar happiness.

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Carrot Cake Mini Cupcake in Pods, Baked By Melissa

Multiple locations

New York, NY

212.842.0220

www.bakedbymelissa.com/

Baked by Melissa, the NYC bakery known for miniature stuffed cupcakes is trick-or-treating friendly this year with a single cupcake package called “Cupcake Pod.” This little container holds one bite-size Carrot Cake Cupcake (made with chocolate chip carrot cake, cream cheese icing and chocolate chips) and is designed to keep the cake and icing perfectly intact all night long, so you’ll be the coolest apartment on the block as you hand these out on October 31st!

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Halloween Cupcakes, Billy’s Bakery

Multiple locations

New York , NY

212.647.9956

www.billysbakerynyc.com/

Billy’s classic cupcakes, including Yellow Daisy and Classic Chocolate with chocolate and vanilla buttercream are topped with spooky sprinkles and a vintage Halloween pick this season. While locals love their banana cupcake, you also shouldn’t miss their other fall treats like the Pumpkin Bar and Apple Spice Cake with Caramel Glaze.

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Halloween Chocolate-Dunked Fortune Cookies, Dylan’s Candy Bar

1011 3rd Avenue

New York, NY

(646) 735-0078

www.dylanscandybar.com/

No matter what the fortune says inside each cookie, your kids will feel pretty lucky to have these crunchy chocolate treats this Halloween. Featuring 12 scarylicious fortune cookies dunked in decadent chocolate, these bites are then topped with edible Halloween decorations and colorful sprinkles.

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Pumpkin Crème Brûlée with Apple Cider Donuts, MexiBBQ

37-11 30th Avenue

Astoria, NY

718.626.0333

mexibbq.com/

MexiBBQ in Astoria will be serving two new pumpkin desserts for the Halloween season. Enjoy Pumpkin Crème Brûlée with Apple Cider Donuts or Pumpkin Panna Cotta. Staying with the autumn theme, MexiBBQ also has a special line of pumpkin beers behind the bar and a few Halloween-themed brews, including Coney Island Freaktober Beer.

 

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Chocolate Clementine Jack-o-Lanterns, Forbidden Fruit

106 MacDougal Street

New York, NY

(212) 671-1222

www.forbiddenfruitnyc.com/

Looking for a treat that won’t ruin your diet this Halloween? Stop by Forbidden Fruit in the West Village, where they’ve turned little seedless clementines into seasonally appropriate faux-pumpkin jack-o-lanterns, dipped in dark or milk chocolate complete with edible sugar details. These fruit and chocolate treats are perfect to get some Vitamin C in with your dessert.

 

NYC’s 10 Best Halloween Treats & Dessert

Halloween Cupcakes, Sugar Sweet Sunshine

126 Rivington St

New York, NY

(212) 995-1960

www.sugarsweetsunshine.com/

Love Sugar Sweet Sunshine’s Pumpkin cupcake all year round? Can’t get enough of their Sassy Red Velvet cupcake (Red Velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream)? You’re in luck this Halloween, as all of their delicious cupcake flavors will be available with black and orange Halloween sprinkles and themed plastic picks for an adorable old school decoration to bring along to any holiday party this month. And while you’re there, don’t forget to try their seasonal Pumpkin Pudding, named one of the best pumpkin treats in NYC.

 

For more from the Best of New York, follow us on Twitter!